Special Instructions: First puzzle, feedback welcome.

Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

15 comments

Really nice! 1a I particularly enjoyed. I did have one thought, which I'll add in a reply to hide spoilers. I've only just published my first crossword so take my feedback with a pinch of salt.

E
A
Last reply 4 wk agoView thread

Thanks EssBee and congrats on your first puzzle. My fave was 3d for the smooth believable surface, also liked 5a, 6a & 4d. If you're in the market for hopefully constructive feedback, spoilers follow ...

E
F
Last reply 4 wk agoView thread

The clue style reminded me of Cyclops a bit. A fun solve - 2d was probably my favourite. I agree with rest of the feedback here, so I'd just add one tiny note...

E
S
Last reply 4 wk agoView thread
Setter

Thanks everybody for the input, and the opportunity to discuss clue writing. Much appreciated.

Very nice, thanks. I enjoyed this along with the various comment threads down below. 1d (fav, really fun), 4d, 5a, 6a were the most satisfying for me. Thanks again, EssBee.

I'm just now getting around to this mini puzzle. I enjoyed solving it! I had a couple niggles that have already been addressed by earlier commenters. I'll put my favorite parts that haven't already been mentioned down in a hidden reply.

w
Last reply last wkView thread