CrosswordsContestsSettersAboutContact
Sign up

Special Instructions: Hi all. This is my first cryptic on MyCrossword.co.uk and perhaps my second ever? I'm very keen to receive all constructive feedback which will be warmly welcomed and appreciated. Thank you. NB: I bumbled my way through the explanations - is there a style guide somewhere?

Sign in to leave a comment

Sign inSign up

Sign in to leave a comment

16 comments

R
RunnyFiddler
Setter

I would love some feedback, if that's possible! TIA

B
Balrog

Hey RunnyFiddler 👋 I'm not really great at feedback but will at least give the puzzle a go and will post on Bluesky encouraging others to take a look too. Matt

F
Fez

Thanks RF and welcome to the site. There are some good ideas and nice surfaces here. My faves were 16a & 1d. Plenty of others were 'nearly there' but not *quite* right in terms of cryptic grammar. As you've asked for constructive feedback, spoilers ...

K
R
F
7 replies
Last reply last wkView thread
K
Kateh

Nice start! Faves included 1a, 8a, 11a, 4d, 13d

F
R
2 replies
Last reply last wkView thread
t
tpgrammar

Hi RunnyFiddler🥄 I hope you don’t mind me poking in here, especially since I haven’t had the chance yet to try your puzzle, but I do so only to encourage you to keep at it. Those who’ve already commented are among the best supporters you can have, and Fez’s extended feedback, as you’ve already noted, is to be cherished. I know I sure have; here is a bit more from Fez that you might find enjoyment/value in: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=L5UCCWQw0V0 All the best.

t
R
2 replies
Last reply last wkView thread