Special Instructions: This puzzle is a present for my Dad's partner and her family, constructive feedback appreciated! 19a involves a tiny bit of personal knowledge :)

Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

16 comments

Very nice. Thank-you. I liked 12A, 15a, 2d, 1&14d and 22d in particular.

G
j
Last reply 5 mo agoView thread

Welcome to the site, Gillafox. I don't know whether the SI indicate that this is a one off or whether we'll be seeing more of you? I hope we do: this was a solid first puzzle with some very neat bits in it. A few quibbles but nothing to prevent a solve, even without the personal knowledge. I am sure the recipients will enjoy it. Faves inc 9a, 10a, 15a, 25a, 1d/14d, 4d, 18d. Thanks. PM

G
P
Last reply 5 mo agoView thread

Thanks Gillafox and welcome to MyC! This is a very accomplished debut puzzle, which I am sure will be warmly received by your Dad’s partner and family. I agree with the detailed feedback that you have already had, so will just focus on some favourites: 9a, 26a (good revision!), 1d 14d (slightly loose def forgiven), 4d and 18d.

G
Last reply 5 mo agoView thread

Thanks Gillafox for a very good debut. I particularly enjoyed 1a, 12a, 13d, 18d, and 26a. More in reply ...

G
G
Last reply 5 mo agoView thread