Cryptic crossword No 892
Wed 21 Dec 2022, set byPixie
15
Special Instructions: My first cryptic crossword here. Partly a themed tribute to someone (JLC) but generally solvable.
Sign in to leave a comment
Sign in to leave a comment
Hello MyCrossword community. This is my first cryptic crossword to be shared in public, and it still has some issues (including a tweak or two too far on the grid to fit more themed solutions), but I think it's a fair record of my starting point, so up it has gone. Thanks in advance for any solves or comments.
Hi Pixie, thanks for a lovely debut puzzle and welcome to MyC! This was a satisfying solve, and you've constructed a some great clues, particularly 1a (neat), 12a (clean), 14a (neat), 28a (cute), 31a (very clean), 32a (simple but effective), 2d (neat), 7d (very neat), 10d (one of many is fun), 21d (nice assembly), 25d (fun) and 27d (fun all round). Lots to like and very little to quibble, lovely stuff and keep em coming. Merry Christmas!
Hi Pixie and, indeed, a warm welcome to MyCrossword. A lovely debut and, as one who enjoys surfaces, I thought you came up with a lovely set of intriguing images. Nicely crafted. Favourites included: 1a (nice that it's NOT a palindrome!), 13a (nice def), 14a (clever), 28a (lol), 32a (nice Lynne Truss ref), 34a (just lovely), 3d (nice def), 5d (not difficult but surface is lol), 7d (delightful), 11d (nice nonsensical image), 27d (it helped that I work with one so named). Spoilers in Reply.
Nice work. You clearly know what you're doing, and it's good to read that this won't be a one-off. For me, it's an extra bonus if a crossword has very few suffixes in the answers, as is the case here. 31A was new to me, and that's OK, but your use of a noun as an anagram indicator threw me, and some editors wouldn't let you get away with that. I'm also unconvinced about how 12A reads. I don't think you can say 'Scatter ... will', but I'm being a bit pedantic there.
Thanks Pixie, good fun - as others have noted, a fair few rough edges to address, especially removing unnecessary "filler", but lots of nice ideas, 28a in particular, but also things like the definitions in 13a and 15a suggest more fun puzzles to come. Other faves include 23a & 9d. Thanks again, looking forward to more from Pixie!
37 comments