Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

32 comments

This is terrific from top to bottom, Coot, with 5a, 10a, 28a, 29a, 30a, 1d, 3d, 4d, 16d, 27d all class in my book. 25a had me wondering what on earth was going on in the auditorium though, lol.

C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread
Setter

Some incidental background to this puzzle in barely spoilery replies …

C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Very nice, Coot. 10a my favourite by a long chalk, but I'll also single out 13a, 3d, and 27d as being particularly good

C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Thanks Coot, that was a great display of masterful setting. My top picks were 5a, 10a, 1d, 3d, 4d 14d 24d, and 7d. More in reply.

C
G
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Solid puzzle, quite approachable compared with some of your other works of late. 30a, 31a, 4d/14d/24d all earned ticks but I agree with Amoeba that 10a steals the show. Thanks. PM

P
C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Very nice, thanks Coot. Faves include 10a of course & also 17a, 29a, 31a, 1d, 4d 14d 24d, 9d & 27d. Spoilers ...

C
F
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Magnificent – anyone would think you did this professionally!! 10a’s hilarious, 12a’s funny and 28a made me smile. I especially enjoyed 29a, 30a, 1d, 4d+, and 22d. I must remember “marches”. Smart. Non-niggles …

C
A
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Great! Nothing to add to what's already been said. Not a duff clue in there!

C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Great stuff, thanks Coot. Lots of great clues, I'll pick out 10a, 11a, 30a, 8d and 27d as favourites.

C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Lots to like. Especially enjoyed 4,14,24d. Haven't personally seen 'marches' used before as in 22d (not a criticism, btw)

C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Late to this particular soirée but glad I came! Super throughout but the plaudits that met 10a are very well-deserved, a superb clue 👌

C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Enjoyed this, thank you. Approachable, although done over two sittings. Lots to like, including 10a, 28a, 30a, 1d, 8d, 27d...

C
C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Thanks Coot! Fun puzzle. 10a 13a 15a my faves!

C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread